Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Review


What's the deal with Whiskeyfellow and flavored whiskeys?  Has he gone over the edge?  No, I've not. I've just had an opportunity to try several of these and rather than just passing them off, I believe it is best to share my thoughts with you so those of you who are interested in flavored whiskeys can make an educated decision, just like with any other whiskey I review.


Today's whiskey is Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey.  This one, like when Fireball was introduced, has taken the market by storm. It isn't a cheap whiskey, a bottle will set you back about $29.99.  


Skrewball was invented by Steven and Brittany Yeng, owners of O.B. Noodlehouse and Bar 1502 in Ocean Beach, California. This was something they served to their patrons, who have been described as "misfits, black sheep, and screwballs" of the community. Brittany got the brand up and going, and the rest is history.


Made from whiskey, natural flavors, and caramel coloring, Skrewball is bottled at 70°.  It carries no age statement, but being a liqueur, you can't assume anything from that.  The distiller of the whiskey itself is undisclosed. Caramel coloring is caramel coloring. But, what catches the eye on the back of the bottle is a warning label:


So, yes, apparently the natural flavoring is from real peanuts!  While I would assume there isn't an issue simply opening the bottle in the venue of someone with a peanut allergy, I'd certainly recommend being careful around them so as to not accidentally cause any issues.


My first opportunity to taste Skrewball was at a family birthday party.  Someone started passing along a bottle, it came to me and I tried it.  SPOILER:  I enjoyed it.  I enjoyed it so much I went out and got a bottle.  Why?  I'll give you the details...


In my Glencairn glass, Skrewball appears as caramel color. Again, being artificially colored, it means nothing. However, it left a medium-thick rim that generated a huge, wavy curtain and medium legs that slowly crawled back to the pool of whiskey.


The aroma?  Let's get real.  This is a peanut-butter flavored whiskey.  I smelled peanut butter. Not just peanuts, but processed peanut butter. When I inhaled through my lips, it was peanut butter and a hint of vanilla. Anything else was indiscernible.


Skrewball has an amazingly thick and rich mouthfeel, even a bit sticky - just like peanut butter. The stickiness is typical of many liqueurs and wasn't completely unexpected. On the palate, it wasn't just peanut butter. There was also vanilla and then, my mind figured out this was honey roasted peanuts. 


The finish gave some warmth to remind you it is made from whiskey and not just a kiddie drink. But that thick peanut butter remained for a long finish.


For kicks and giggles, I made myself a cocktail of Skrewball and Godiva White Chocolate Liqueur. If you've ever had a Reeses white chocolate peanut butter cup, this was a darned good copy of it, even down to the creamy texture. No ice needed.


Bottle, Bar or Bust:  Well, the spoiler earlier makes this rating moot, but I want consistency in my reviews. Spend the $30 and get yourself a Bottle. Skrewball is a flavored whiskey worth having around. Cheers!


Postscript:  In all the years I've been writing reviews, I've never felt the need to add a postscript until today. This review has been "live" for about 48 hours and the social media response has been amazing, to say the least. Essentially, people either love Skewball or they have found it disgusting. There have been 250+ comments and not a single one suggests it is just okay or decent. The polarization is unbelievable. Cheers!

Comments

  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  2. After a few minutes did you have a lingering after taste? Or like PB just a good taste. I can't imagine it being good. But the price it what's keeping me from pulling the trigger. Lol I'm a fireball fan. Usually a bar shot before heading up to the room.🥃😋🤠CHEERS

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tried this last night for the first time. I may never drink wine again! DELICIOUS!

    ReplyDelete
  4. This “after dinner drink” puts Fireball, Doctor, Sambuca, even Limoncello on the second shelf. It’s so smooth and flavorful. 5 stars from me. ,

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have a severe allergy to peanuts and unfortunately wasn't paying attention when a new friend offered me a shot. Took the shot then checked the bottle, bad move. Ran outside proceded to throw up my entire stomach and take a fistful of benadryl and hope I don't end up in the hospital. It's been over 30 min and I don't feel anything, this is my experience don't trust me with your life. Ngl though its good even if it kills me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Literally experiencing this right now. I have severe allergies and discovered what I just had in the same way you did. I live close to the bar I was at so I rushed home and was on stanby with an epi-pen. 2 hours pass and I was okay... I researched that they remove the allergens and proteins. But like you said, our bodies are different so there's no guarantee that anyone else won't have a reaction.

      Lastly, I too agree, that shot was DAMN GOOD!!

      Delete
  6. i can taste coconut .i love the taste!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

As we should drink in moderation, all comments are subject to it. Cheers!