Blue Note Barrel Proof Tennessee Straight 17-Year Bourbon Review

 


I know that I will ruffle feathers for saying this: Age statements, like proof declarations, are great marketing tools.

 

Over these many years, I’ve reviewed more than 1500 whiskeys. I’m here to tell you that I’ve had gorgeous, ancient whiskeys and I’ve had lovely ones that spent only a handful of years in oak. I’ve had fantastic barrel proof selections and characterful 80-proofers. I’ve also had too many that were overoaked, painfully hot, or so watered down that they might as well have been vodkas.

 

Long story short: Age and proof are just numbers.  

 

For Scotch whiskies, finding something at least 17 years old isn’t much of a challenge. For American whiskeys, that’s a big hurdle. Why? Because Scotch, for the most part, uses vintage oak, whereas many American options must, by law, be aged in virgin oak. The longer that whiskey interacts with new wood, the greater the chances that a whiskey will be overoaked. If that happens, a distiller can attempt to salvage it in one of three ways: Lower the proof, blend it, or use a finishing cask; oh yeah, don’t forget to pray.

 

As such, when a barrel-proof, 17-year-old, unfinished Bourbon appears in my hands, my curiosity is naturally piqued. Such is the story with Blue Note Barrel Proof Tennessee Straight 17-Year Bourbon.

 

“We’re excited to bring back a 17-Year whiskey which reflects the patience, craftsmanship and time required to create something truly special. It has been several years since we’ve released an expression of this caliber, making this limited release a rare opportunity for collectors and discerning whiskey enthusiasts to experience this remarkable expression which reflects the depth, character and complexity that comes with extended aging.” - Chris Crosbie, Chief Executive Officer, B.R. Distilling Co.

 

Blue Note Barrel Proof Tennessee Straight 17-Year Bourbon is available online via Seelbach’s (beginning November 20) and at limited U.S. retailers for the suggested retail price of $174.99. It is packaged at 59.5% ABV (119°).

 

When the actual distiller is undisclosed, I enjoy trying to track down who it might have been. There aren’t that many Tennessee distillers who might have 17-year-old Bourbon stocks on-hand. And no, we will not get into a debate about whether Tennessee Whiskey is Bourbon because, per the TTB, it is.

 

The quandary is: which distillers were making Bourbon from a mashbill of 70% corn, 22% rye, and 8% malted barley? That’s not standard for Jack Daniel’s or Cascade Hollow. Interestingly, Prichard’s Distillery is known for whiskeys with very high corn content and has been around since 1997; it is the only Tennessee distillery exempt from using the Lincoln County Process (charcoal mellowing) to carry “Tennessee Whiskey” on the label. Yet, its mashbill isn’t public. I’m unsure of any others that could seriously be considered.

 

At the end of the day, at least to me, the only thing that really matters is what a whiskey smells and tastes like. Thankfully, B.R. Distilling was kind enough to send me a sample of its Blue Note Barrel Proof Tennessee Straight 17-Year Bourbon in exchange for my no-strings-attached, honest review. Let’s #DrinkCurious and determine if it is worth the price of admission.

 

  • Whiskey Type: Straight Bourbon
  • Distiller: Undisclosed Tennessee distillery
  • Age: 17 years
  • Mashbill: 70% corn, 22% rye, and 8% malted barley
  • Cooperage: New, 53-gallon charred oak barrel
  • Alcohol Content: 59.5% ABV (119°)
  • Price per 750mL: $174.99
  • Unfiltered
  • 4000 bottle yield

 

Appearance: I poured Blue Note into my Glencairn glass to drink neat. While its burnt-orange color was deep for its age, I had expected something darker. I observed a medium-thick rim shed husky, widely spaced tears.

 

Nose: Normally, I would wait about 15 minutes before nosing a whiskey. However, due to its age, I gave it another 5 minutes. When I brought the glass beneath my nostrils and inhaled, dense brown sugar was the first thing I smelled. As I continued to sniff, I found aged oak, old leather, black cherries, and a bit of nutmeg. Next, I drew the air into my mouth, only to discover torched sugar.

 

Palate: My first sip revealed an incredibly thin, slick texture and one heck of a punch of dry oak. I took another; this time I tasted brown sugar, plums, and powdered cocoa on the front of my palate. Caramel, honey, and Red Delicious apples hit my mid-palate, while the back included notes of what may be prehistoric leather, arid oak, and maple syrup.

 

Finish: After the swallow, what remained in my mouth and throat were maple syrup, ripe plums, Red Delicious apples, brown sugar, leather, and oak. Those last two were the last to fall off, which occurred at 1:07, making for a medium to medium-long duration.

 

Bottle, Bar, or Bust: Again, there aren’t many barrel-proof, 17-year-old Bourbons on the market, making a value statement difficult. The Bourbon, however, was stupidly stunning. Someone paid close attention to these barrels, and I’ll assume they were kept in a cooler environment. That makes me more confident that Prichard’s Distillery is the source – the operation is inside a converted schoolhouse rather than traditional rickhouses used throughout Tennessee and Kentucky.

 

I loved Blue Note Barrel Proof Tennessee Straight 17-Year Bourbon. The oak was strong without being debilitating. It drank closer to something around 100° rather than its stated proof. I loved the fruitiness it maintained while balancing the earthy, savory, and spicy components.

 

Sure, this is expensive, but how many opportunities like this do you have? Only my Bottle rating can be considered. Cheers!



  

My Simple, Easy-to-Understand Rating System

  • Bottle = Buy It
  • Bar = Try It
  • Bust = Leave It

 

Whiskeyfellow encourages you to enjoy your whiskey as you see fit, but begs you to do so responsibly.

 


Comments